Lots more great pizzas in Hamilton! A brand new one that is getting rave reviews is Tony G’s Pizzaria! Brooklyn style pizza with the cup and char pepperones…a great and greasy slice!
Also recommend Flora Pizza, Castelli and Cafe Baffico (newly making sourdough pizzas on weekends only).
Main Street Pizza Company in Batavia NY. Known for their Chicago style deep dish make sure you try that. Regular pizza is also amazing and they’re 20inch larges. I drive from Buffalo for this pizza it’s TO DIE FOR
Chops Shop in Gasport NY. Absolutely BEST Pizza. They have a sweet and original sauce. Both are great but the sweet sauce is where it’s at and with Garlic Crust. Wednesdays you can grab a large Pizza and Fried Dough for just $21. What?!! I’ve pizza from many places like Imperial, Abbott, Macy’s Place, Master pizza, Just Pizza, Maxi’s, Bella, Blasdell, and a few others all over NY in Rochester, NYC, Syracuse, and Chops Shop takes the crown over all. My top 3 are #1. Chops Shop #2. Picasso’s and #3. Macy’s Place.
Try Chops Shop, You wont regret it and will never have a better tasting Pizza in the WNY area.
Main Street Pizza Company in Batavia NY!! Best pizza in NY state we drive from buffalo just to get it. Make sure you try the Chicago style deep dish!!! It’s better than Chicago in my opinion!!
Hey Joe, I watch your interviews and I think your spot on on your scoring. I just wanted to make a suggestion. I’m a 61 year old former Greek Pizza entrepreneur from back in the ’80s and ’90s in Massachusetts. Long Retired. I now live here in Rochester New York which is not too far from Buffalo where you dine. I have to express that you got to come out to Rochester New York. Whitney Road, Fairport New York. A pizza shop called Pizza Chef. The most amazing, in my opinion and the best pizza that I’ve ever had in Rochester New York. Sure there are many places in Rochester New York and people will argue my selection for other places but after trying many of them there is one I would consider 2cd to this one called The Pizza Stop on Monroe Ave in Pittsford New York. The owner of pizza chef in Fairport is a Hands-On owner (not an absentee)and is in there daily. I don’t have a close friendship with them Imjust cordial customer relations and he’s always watching over his establishment for quality control products and how things are done so it always is consistent and the best tasting Pizza you ever had I always go for the pepperoni and cheese. it’s just amazing so if ever you feel like coming over an hour and 15 minutes longer from Buffalo to Rochester New York I’m sure you’ll be presently pleased with Pizza Chef thank you. ( again I have no affiliation with this establishment just a customer)
Try pizza from Stirling bar in Niagara Falls. This pizza is perfection. It is cooked to perfection every time. They LOAD on the toppings!! The crust is thin and has a slight crunch. It is definitly one of the best pies we have had!
Lots more great pizzas in Hamilton! A brand new one that is getting rave reviews is Tony G’s Pizzaria! Brooklyn style pizza with the cup and char pepperones…a great and greasy slice!
Also recommend Flora Pizza, Castelli and Cafe Baffico (newly making sourdough pizzas on weekends only).
Bella Pizza located at 4909 Lakeshore Rd in Hamburg, NY has been delivering the best pizza since 1966.
Main Street Pizza Company in Batavia NY. Known for their Chicago style deep dish make sure you try that. Regular pizza is also amazing and they’re 20inch larges. I drive from Buffalo for this pizza it’s TO DIE FOR
Chops Shop in Gasport NY. Absolutely BEST Pizza. They have a sweet and original sauce. Both are great but the sweet sauce is where it’s at and with Garlic Crust. Wednesdays you can grab a large Pizza and Fried Dough for just $21. What?!! I’ve pizza from many places like Imperial, Abbott, Macy’s Place, Master pizza, Just Pizza, Maxi’s, Bella, Blasdell, and a few others all over NY in Rochester, NYC, Syracuse, and Chops Shop takes the crown over all. My top 3 are #1. Chops Shop #2. Picasso’s and #3. Macy’s Place.
Try Chops Shop, You wont regret it and will never have a better tasting Pizza in the WNY area.
Jay’s Artisan Pizza in Kenmore, NY(Buffalo)
Main Street Pizza Company in Batavia NY!! Best pizza in NY state we drive from buffalo just to get it. Make sure you try the Chicago style deep dish!!! It’s better than Chicago in my opinion!!
Cowabunga 2 Vine St. Hamilton, ON
Zahz Pizza there’s one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had they are located at 596 Cayuga rd. Cheektowaga, NY 14225.
Jays Artisan Kenmore (Buffalo)
D’Agostino’s Pizzeria Inc.
576 Dick Rd Suite 60, Depew, NY 14043
https://dagostinospizzeria.com/
+17166811211
Never been here. Is this place quality?
Broadway Bobby’s Pizzeria
677 Ridge Road
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Bella
3330 South Park Ave
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Maybe 5 years ago but they gone downhill since. Same with their subs.
Hey Joe, I watch your interviews and I think your spot on on your scoring. I just wanted to make a suggestion. I’m a 61 year old former Greek Pizza entrepreneur from back in the ’80s and ’90s in Massachusetts. Long Retired. I now live here in Rochester New York which is not too far from Buffalo where you dine. I have to express that you got to come out to Rochester New York. Whitney Road, Fairport New York. A pizza shop called Pizza Chef. The most amazing, in my opinion and the best pizza that I’ve ever had in Rochester New York. Sure there are many places in Rochester New York and people will argue my selection for other places but after trying many of them there is one I would consider 2cd to this one called The Pizza Stop on Monroe Ave in Pittsford New York. The owner of pizza chef in Fairport is a Hands-On owner (not an absentee)and is in there daily. I don’t have a close friendship with them Imjust cordial customer relations and he’s always watching over his establishment for quality control products and how things are done so it always is consistent and the best tasting Pizza you ever had I always go for the pepperoni and cheese. it’s just amazing so if ever you feel like coming over an hour and 15 minutes longer from Buffalo to Rochester New York I’m sure you’ll be presently pleased with Pizza Chef thank you. ( again I have no affiliation with this establishment just a customer)
Pizza Amore
1030 Payne Ave, North Tonawanda, NY 14120
Try pizza from Stirling bar in Niagara Falls. This pizza is perfection. It is cooked to perfection every time. They LOAD on the toppings!! The crust is thin and has a slight crunch. It is definitly one of the best pies we have had!
BELLA PIZZA on South Park in Lackawanna, NY
Cowabunga 2 30 Vine St. Hamilton ON.
Marios Pizza…Mohawk Rd E. & Upper Wellington St…in a Plaza beside Sparkles Cannabis Store….Hamilton, Ontario.
Grassos Pizza dam good pizza
Cowabunga 2 Vine St. Hamilton ON
Dom DeMarco’s
9785 West Charleston Blvd.
Ypu need to try these great places
Flora pizza
Sasso
Cima
Castelli
Ypu need to try these great places in Hamilton.
Flora pizza
Sasso
Cima
Castelli
Pizza Rock Vegas!
It’s Tony Gemignanis spot. He’s the Top guy in the country Right now. Let’s see what ya think