You have to try Bella Pizza in Lakawana. It is a perfect sauce, and a perfect ratio of dough/sauce/cheese/cup n char. I know you are doing plain cheese/pep, but my favorite way to order the cheese/pep is well done with garlic crust.
3330 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY
I have tried a lot of pies around buffalo! Below are/were my go to’s:
Bella
OG Santoras
Leonardis (RIP)
Picassos
Ninos
Also, here is a buffalo style sauce recipe I came up with for home pies:
Add to blender, pulse till chunky, and refrigerate overnight:
1 28oz can San Marzano Tomatoes (just the tomatoes, discard the liquid)
1 6oz can tomato paste
2-3 tsp sugar
1.5 tsp basil
1.5 tsp oregeno
1 tsp granulated garlic
.5 tsp Marjoram
While you’re trying pies over the River, you should totally hit up Sammy’s in Niagara Falls, NY! It’s the only place I think I’ve went for pizza and wings over the river, we usually get the tray but they have cup and char pep!
Hey Joe, we enjoy Burattino pizza here in California. Stumbled across you on Instagram. Enjoy your reviews and think you should try the Burattino’s in Toronto!
There’s only one Joe and you know the rules! Let’s go!!!
La Hacienda,Gagsters ,Mister B’s and Sammy’s
All in Niagara Falls NY
Main st Pizzeria in Lewiston
It’s beside a gas station but a great pie in my opinion
Also another local favorite of mine (not your traditional cup and char buffalo is know for) but it is JOSH Allens favorite too … NEW YORK STYLE , Ferro’s also in West Seneca
Fb link: https://www.facebook.com/ferrosfamousnypizza?mibextid=LQQJ4d
Try T.C. Wheelers on wheeler st in the city of tonawanda! Best pizza around! They have other awesome food as well! Tell me when you go and I will meet you there if you would like!
Pudgies pizza, give that a try!
You have to try Bella Pizza in Lakawana. It is a perfect sauce, and a perfect ratio of dough/sauce/cheese/cup n char. I know you are doing plain cheese/pep, but my favorite way to order the cheese/pep is well done with garlic crust.
3330 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY
I have tried a lot of pies around buffalo! Below are/were my go to’s:
Bella
OG Santoras
Leonardis (RIP)
Picassos
Ninos
Also, here is a buffalo style sauce recipe I came up with for home pies:
Add to blender, pulse till chunky, and refrigerate overnight:
1 28oz can San Marzano Tomatoes (just the tomatoes, discard the liquid)
1 6oz can tomato paste
2-3 tsp sugar
1.5 tsp basil
1.5 tsp oregeno
1 tsp granulated garlic
.5 tsp Marjoram
That is amazing! Do you ever want to trade me a jar of that sauce for a Pizza after a review? Hit me in the DM!
Check out Edie’s Pizza in Hamburg, NY. It’s about 20 minutes South of Downtown Buffalo. Best pizza in WNY IMO.
https://www.ediespizza.com/
Papa’s Pizzeria .Lake n Como Park Blvd Lancaster,NY
La Nova Pizza
371 W Ferry Street, Buffalo, New York
14213 United States
Buzzys
7617 Niagara Falls Blvd.
Niagara Falls, New York 14304
You need to try Sammy’s in niagara falls ny. On hyde Park Blvd. The best pizza state side!!
Definitely try out Palumbos pizza in Tonawanda NY best place in town man 1065 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Mister Pizza Elmwood has always been a favorite of ours. Give it a try if you are in the area.
Queens pizza and wings upper paradise and stone church Hamilton Ontario.
While you’re trying pies over the River, you should totally hit up Sammy’s in Niagara Falls, NY! It’s the only place I think I’ve went for pizza and wings over the river, we usually get the tray but they have cup and char pep!
Hey Joe, we enjoy Burattino pizza here in California. Stumbled across you on Instagram. Enjoy your reviews and think you should try the Burattino’s in Toronto!
There’s only one Joe and you know the rules! Let’s go!!!
Lol thank ya! Is it the same franchise in Cali and TO?
Yes it is
La Hacienda,Gagsters ,Mister B’s and Sammy’s
All in Niagara Falls NY
Main st Pizzeria in Lewiston
It’s beside a gas station but a great pie in my opinion
Hey Joe,
You have to try
Leon’s Italian Bistro & Pizza
8890 Porter Rd, Niagara Falls, NY 14304, United States
While you’re there try a slice of the Buffalo chicken if you can and the cannoli! 🤤
Also, Mr. Ventry’s Pizza on the Boulevard
10051 Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY 14304, United States
Bella Pizza! (Boston, NY)
5699 Herman Hill Rd
Boston, NY 14075
United States
https://www.bellapizza.com/
Forno Napoli!
1280 Sweet Home Rd
Buffalo, NY 14228
United States
https://fornonapoliny.com/
https://www.facebook.com/FornoNapoli?mibextid=LQQJ4d
Carbone’s buffalo, ny
Try the Sweet sauce if you don’t want to try both sauces.
Bonus review try there bread sticks!
The Mayors in North Tonawanda. Slightly sweet sauce, cup and char. 452 Oliver Street, North Tonawanda. 716-389-0052.
A great local joint , TKs pizza in West Seneca
Fb link: https://www.facebook.com/TKpizza?mibextid=LQQJ4d
Also another local favorite of mine (not your traditional cup and char buffalo is know for) but it is JOSH Allens favorite too … NEW YORK STYLE , Ferro’s also in West Seneca
Fb link: https://www.facebook.com/ferrosfamousnypizza?mibextid=LQQJ4d
Wise guys pizza, a great little joint on Senica Street. You won’t be disappointed.
Joe you should absolutely check out Lovejoy pizza on Lovejoy st in buffalo. They have a main st location as well but the LJ spot is where it’s at.
Picasso’s Pizza in Buffalo is a must. My favorite out of the three is on Transit Rd. Amazing pizza
If you’re in Rochester, MN this is the place to go! https://www.rochestermnpizza.com/
Nonni’s Pizzeria in Grimsby
on Livingston Ave.
Thin & crispy with Cup & char pepperoni! One of the best around.
Wise Guys South Buffalo
Try T.C. Wheelers on wheeler st in the city of tonawanda! Best pizza around! They have other awesome food as well! Tell me when you go and I will meet you there if you would like!
Donatello’s
466 3rd street
Niagara Falls NY 14301
Imperial Pizza
1035 Abbott Rd, Buffalo, NY 14220
11am-10pm Everyday
Picasso’s on broadway st in Lancaster
Santoras on Clinton and transit in Lancaster
Galassi’s Sub Shop
452 Payne Avenue
North Tonawanda
Specialty subs. The Nightmare
Specialty pizza. Chicken pickle
Picasso’s pizza in buffalo all 3 locations amazing 🔥🔥
Metro pizza. 920 Clinton st buffalo ny
Joe,
Try this Pizza place in Guelph. They got cup and char. Its New York Style.
Roy’s Pizza
(519) 265-0501
https://g.co/kgs/KxTv3Z
Imperial Pizza
1035 Abbott Rd
Buffalo, NY 14220
La Hacienda Ristorante. Niagara falls ny. On pine Ave. Yummy.