Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,207 Responses
  1. Darrell Lindahl

    Hey Joe….. check out Village Pizza in Middleport NY….great pie and great price….. while your there walk around the corner to Ponys for some awesome chicken wings.

  2. John

    Bella Pizza on South Park in Lackawanna, NY should be on your short list, then visit Edie’s Pizza in Hamburg, NY. Two of my favorites!

  3. Dan J

    IF you Happen to make it to Rochester, Ny – Which I highly recommend you should

    Carbones Pizza – Dewey ave- Greece
    Tom n Nancys Pizza- Stone rd. – Greece
    DeLindas Pizza- Dewey ave- Greece
    Russo’s Clubhouse – Long pong rd. Greece
    Good Guys Pizza- Chili
    Tk’s Pizzeria – Fairport

  4. Dan J

    If you decide to make it to Rochester, Ny – Which I think you most definitely should:

    Carbones – Dewey Ave -Greece – MUST TRY!
    Tom n Nancys- Stone Rd – Greece
    Russo’s Club House- Long Pong Rd – Greece
    DeLindas – Dewey ave – Greece
    Good Guys – Chili ave
    TK’s Pizzeria – Liftbridge ln- Fairport

    1. BigC1027

      Silver Beach Pizza & Mr. Scribbs. Check them out in Michigan
      Southwest Michigan – Silver Beach Pizza
      West Michigan – Mr. Scribbs Pizza
      Big-C.

  5. Jenn

    Can you do a review on Maria’s pizza on route 5 in Angola, NY? It is some of the best pizza and the only pizza my kids and fiance will eat.

  6. Mark DiStasio

    IF Joe makes it to NYC for reviews some day then he has to make the trip to the pizza capital of America; New Haven, Connecticut for the Big 3:

    Sally’s Apizza
    Pepe’s Pizza
    Modern Apizza

  7. Kevin

    Joe can you go to Bella Pizza on South Park in Blasdell NY I really think you’ll enjoy the pizza. Love the reviews keep up the good work.

  8. Joe Volpini

    Every Tuesday The Eastern Market Buy 1 get 1 free. For $12.99. Upper Wentworth, Hamilton ON. Directly across from Limeridge Mall.

    1. Kevin Russell

      Bella and Blasdell Pizza both on South Park Ave in Lackawanna and Blasdell respectively (approx 4-5 kms apart). Buffalo area staple pizza, cup n char, both with multiple locations and have been in business for years. Enjoy!🍕👍

  9. Joe Volpini

    Super Torino’s Pizza and Wings 521 Hwy 8 Stoney Creek ON I’ve heard it’s very good. Eastern Food Market. Buy 1 get 1 free pizza cooked on a wood oven. 920 Upper Wentworth St. Directly across from Limeridge Mall. Checkers Pizza six-sixty-five Plains Rd. E Burlington ON. Be there.

  10. Mike Balser

    Okay, my top place in buffalo, NY is LoveJoy pizza. 1244 E lovejoy st. Is the address of it. Their pizza comes out perfect every time. It does not matter if it’s superbowl Sunday or a random week night. Always cooked perfectly. I also have them do sesame crust.

  11. Hello pizza man joe, as a fellow pizza lover myself, I have tasted endless amount of cheese, sauces and doughs , some better then others. So I ask you what do you look for in a perfect pie? Is it the cup and char pep, or the stretch of the cheese? If not that it must be the dough right? At this very point I have not found the perfect pie, maybe never will but pizza oven on 54 vine street in lockport ny 14094 just might be close to it. The combination of the sauce,cheese, and pep is a pizza lovers dream. Make sure to hit that spot. If you need a partner to tear that pizza up I’m your guy! From one pizza lover to another.

  12. Hello my name is Chris and me and my family have recently moved from fl to barker ny to partner up with my in laws and buy a pizza restaurant! We are the Grain house of barker eatery and taproom! We have amazing pizza and fresh locally sourced prime angus burgers! I make pizza the old school way with a touch of new school! We would be delighted to have you come join us for a meal one day so we can show the rest of western ny what this new restaurant has to offer!

  13. Mike C

    Please try Mr. Pizza on Bird and Elmwood Ave. no way they score lower than 9.

    Been trying for months to get you to try it!! Let’s Gooooo!

Leave a Reply