Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,206 Responses
  1. Hi Joe – my recommendation is Tuscan Wolf Pizzeria in Whitby. wood oven is used which produces a delicious thin crust pie. Won’t disappoint!!

  2. Eric Tertinek

    OK Joe.

    Unlike the Tonawandas, you won’t get shot, mugged or have your car stolen in Buffalos Southtowns. (West Seneca & Orchard Park). You will be able to knock all five of these out in a few hours.

    Sonny Reds – Wood fired in a pizza oven named Bruno
    Picasso’s- We are Buffalo Pizza
    Nino’s – One of my personal favorites.
    Ferro’s – Josh Allen’s favorite pie
    Pasquale’s- Very popular

    Stay safe! I wouldn’t steer you wrong.

    1. Anonymous

      Picasso overpriced and overrated just like imperial. Pasquale I’m no waste of time. Never had a good pie there. Ninos is like frozen Tony’s pizza

  3. Paul Grigoriadis

    Hi Joe if you get a chance try pizza di nonna is Grimsby on lake st and Bartlett Vito the owner has a great dough pizza is amazing

  4. KMJ

    Submasters in North Tonawanda pizza is definitely worth checking out for a review. I always loved the way they make it

  5. Joe Phister

    Check out WingNutz on Niagara Falls Blvd. Pizza is phenomenal and the wings are even better! WingNutz Mild sauce..

  6. Gary B.

    If you are in WNY, you have to try Chops Shop Pizza in Rochester Road (Route 31). The pizza is very good, along with everything else…he does Garlic Knot sliders too (pot roast, philly cheese steak, Reubens, etc.). For the puzza, when they ask if you want garlic, say yes….its fantastic.

  7. Kevin Funk

    Joe your reviews are seriously the best man. Last suggestion for you. Daddios Pizza 1247 Hertel Ave Buffalo. It’s right up there with Imperial/Macy’s. Take care dude!!

  8. Andrea Burdick

    If you want a good cup and char try jacos pizza in Niagara falls ny . Or Fred’s pizza in pendleton ny. They both have good sweet sauce and cup and char

  9. Al S.

    DiCamillo Bakery, 7927 Niagara Falls Blvd. NFNY.

    I live in Florida now and coming back to NFNY in May to visit. I’ll be filling up my car with DiCamillo pizza. It’s bakery style but you have to taste it. Cheese only with Romano and parmesan. I asked one time what the other pizza was on the shelf below and they said pepperoni with mozzarella….”we don’t sell much of that”. I’ll be freezing 3 trays and it’s fantastic in the air fryer or right from the store. Favorite pizza in NFNY!!!

  10. Brenda

    Pizza Shack on NF Blvd it’s in Niagara wheatfield but it’s an NT zip code it’s about a block past NT border

Leave a Reply