Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,206 Responses
  1. Lock City
    379 Davison Rd
    Lockport NY 14094

    Old school pizza, lots of cheese and pepperoni, classic crust with cornmeal on the bottom. Hearth oven baked. Very well respected pizza shop in central Niagara county.

  2. Sally Sheppard

    Jt’s pizza on Sheidan dr is awesome. Sauce made daily from owners secret recipe 😋. Crust is cook just right & many topping to choose from. We are frequent flyers there. Owners treat every employee & customer like family. All food excellent but omg gotta try 🍕

  3. Bill Leonard

    If you can make it down to Angola NY, south of Buffalo, you should check out:

    1) Maria’s
    2) Pat’s
    3) Pasquale’s (technically, in Derby the next town over!)

  4. Tommy Cavanaugh

    SEBASTIAN’S , in Gloucester, Mass., has the BEST pizza in that town…. Their Linguisa/ Pep pizza is just AWESOME…. (Unfortunately there aren’t any pizza shops to compare it to around WNY, because there aren’t any pizza shops that I know of, who use Linguisa)….. As for WNY Pizza, I like Leon’s, and Buzzy’s, in Niagara Falls….. Galasi’s, in NT is really good, and their subs are FANTASTIC!

    1. Jorge Gonzalez

      HEY MY NAME IS JORGE IAM THE OWNER OF PAPIS FAMILY PIZZA 🍕 I WOULD LOVE FOR YOU TO COME CHECK US OUT WE HAVE AMAZING FRESH DOUGH MAKE WITH OUR secret pizza source
      THANK YPU AND CANT WAIT FOR YPU TO CHECK US OUT

    2. Arthur Jankowski

      There’s a place in taylor, Michigan called pias pizza that’s if it’s still there I haven’t been up there in years anyway they had the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life you should try it

  5. Stacey

    Sullivans Taproom in Kilkenny Ireland has the most talented Italian guys working in the kitchen who lovingly make a beautiful 72hour fermented dough which is so incredibly light and chewy. Their oven is kept around 400′ resulting in that all important leoparding on the crust from the caramalisation process in the heat.

    All toppings have been carefully selected with thw Italian Sausage being my favourite.

    The venue is so cool and has a deep history in Kilkenny with the original brewery opening in 1702. These guys have the best beer garden and pizza in town

  6. You need to Try Brando’s in North Tonawanda or their Niagara Falls location. We love the Niagara Falls location.

    Brando’s
    9121 Buffalo Ave
    Niagara Falls, NY

  7. Anthony Sebastian

    I love Mineo’s South pizza and I think you will also, they’re at 2154 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY 14220. Also, if you’ve already reviewed their pizza try La Pizza Club so good located at 1511 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216.

Leave a Reply