Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,246 Responses
  1. Chad Bird

    Santora’s Drive in Pizza.
    Dope N.Y on East Senneca. Great pizza and I think they make their own pepperoni. I drive down from Welland Ontario.

  2. Hey Joe love your reviews. When in Buffalo you gotta go to strikers lanes in west seneca ny and get a large cheese and pep. Best in town. Also the bar next door called 240 south has an amazing pie as well. Please check them out you won’t be disappointed.

  3. joseph monaco

    You have to go to this place,I guarantee you won’t be disappointed.
    Georgie’s Pizzeria Prince O’ Pie.
    11891 Main Road in Akron, NY
    (716) 442-5333

    (716) 442-5355

  4. Nina

    I recommend, Good Guys in Tonawanda, Picassos in West Seneca, Desis in Buffalo on Clinton, Bella Pizza in Lackawanna, Ninos in West Seneca on orchard park rd. Abbott Pizza in Buffalo on Abbott rd, and Edies in Hamburg.

  5. Tim “Doodles” Jezioro

    Bada Bing Pizza on Chippewa Street downtown Buffalo. Order the sesame crust. You won’t be disappointed

  6. Carlos Tejada

    Hey Joe –

    The 2 pizza places you need to try in Western New York are:
    1. Maria’s Pizza – 9120 Erie Road, Angola, NY 14006
    2. Plaza Pizzeria on Main – 260 Main Street, Tonawanda, NY 14150

    Best Pizza in Buffalo!

    Carlos

    1. James Jurek

      Awesome Pizza nice cook semi sweet sauce plenty of cheese not sure if it’s Batastoni cup and char but always plenty and tasty
      Pasquale’s West Seneca
      Pasquale’s.com
      You have to try it

    2. James jurek

      Pasquale’s West Seneca NY
      A have to try pizza
      Great cook,semi sweet sauce plenty of cheese and pepperoni
      My go to pizza
      Consistent !

  7. I used to live in Lockport NY for 3 years. The whole time I lived there, I never found a good place for pizza. I worked at Walmart and asked around for recommendations from the locals. Everyone seemed to be pointing me to:

    Molinaros
    3o Walnut st
    Lockport NY

    The consensus was to order the sweet sauce. I did and thought it was terrible; never went back.

    I’d really like to have your feedback in a review to see if the city of Lockport is correct, or crazy.

    Kelly

  8. Howard

    Bob and Johns La Hacienda on Hertel Avenue in Buffalo. I’ve been going there for almost 50 years! Ask for cup and char pepperoni – your favorite!

  9. Ryan Gerow

    Ronny’s Take Out Pizza: Amazing unique flavor to its crust that I find addicting. It just taste so different and filling.

    Pizza Heist: Directly across the intersection from Ronny’s Take Out Pizza, this pizza is also very good and worth a try.

Leave a Reply