Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,244 Responses
  1. Another great Ottawa pizza is Schoolhouse pizza. I’m curious if you think it ranks with the other top Ottawa pizzas. Your other ratings are spot on with ours.

  2. Giovanni Hernandez

    Please try Edie’s pizza in Hamburg NY!! It’s absolutely amazing. Based on your other pizza reviews, I think it’ll be right in your ballpark

  3. Chad

    Hi Joe, love your videos. Noticed you only tried a slab pizza at Italian Peasant Gastro Market so far in Fonthill. They now have 12 inch round thin crust pizza and are delicious

  4. Jack Keane

    You gotta try Pizza Glen Pizza in Glenwood NY. One mile from Kissing Bridge. It’s my sister’s place and it’s really great.

  5. Cheryl grace

    Please go to Garfalo’s on Niagara Falls Blvd in the Wheatfield area! My daughter and I get it like twice a week since trying it months ago.

  6. aaron s owen

    You got to try tony’s pizza in akron, ny. They have been open since the 50’s and have a very good traditional style pizza. The wings are excellent as well with a unique sloppy sauce that is finger licking good. They don’t have social media or a website and is cash only. They have been owned and operated by the same family since they have been around.

  7. Laurie G

    Campos Pizza, 8 Central Avenue, Dunkirk, NY 716-363-6161. Right near the pier on Lake Erie. They are at the Buffalo Italian Festival and their pizza is fantastic!
    At the Italian fest, years ago, a man overheard me saying I would not pay $5 for a slice of pizza. He told me if I bought the pizza and didn’t like it, he would give me the $5 and take my slice of pizza. I bought the slice and loved it. The same man came up to me and told me he makes that offer each year and no one has taken him up on it. Everyone loves the pizza.I get it every year now at the festival.

Leave a Reply