Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,338 Responses
    1. Tammy and Ken Derkovitz of lancaster ny

      Lock City Pizza.
      We never drive thru Lockport without picking up a pie. Great crust. Sexy Slices gave it high rankings too.

  1. Dash’s market Hertel Ave. Surprisingly top notch cheese and pep Neapolitan pizza. Get it well done, large for 15.95, can’t get much better than that. Look forward to seeing you review it.

    1770 Hertel Ave #3002, Buffalo, NY 14216

  2. Hey again. I know you been to palumbos on Sheridan in Kenmore/ tonawanda. It’s a great place that sells good pizza at an affordable price. If you ever get a chance to go back try the Sicilian style pizza. It’s really good. It’s soft and fluffy and still crispy on that bottom because they use a baking sheet. Then the crispy pepperoni takes it to the next level.

  3. Simon MacIvor

    Olive us / pizza and Greek food / Burlington Ontario / great spot 110% recommend going , pizza was always a hassle at my house no one could agree …. Now we all can agree because of olive us pizza ! I think you’ll give it a rating in the high 8s if you give it a try !

  4. Ken Hunter

    You need to try grand central sports bar on queen street niagara falls. I must say in my opinion it’s definitely one of the best thin crust pizza with cup and char pepperoni in niagara that I’ve had and the trick is “the consistency is there” looking forward to seeing your review

  5. Christian Moran

    Hello you should try Krispys pizza in New York. I’ve never been but the pizza looks amazing !

    7112 13th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228, United States

  6. Terry Ciantar

    I have a hidden gem of a great pizza. Try Sanger farms and bakery , 852 lockport st youngstown usa 141754 716 745 7297

    1. Melissa Metcalfe

      Garth Pizza in Hamilton Ontario
      It’s on the corner or Garth and Garrow sooooo good and the garlic dip is made in house sooo yummy!!

  7. If you’re ever in Erie, Pennsylvania, try Colony Pizza and Catering. I’m originally from Buffalo and I love Buffalo style, this is a thinner crust and the owner is from Pittsburgh and it’s the best pizza in Erie.

  8. It’s a real challenge to find even an edible gluten free pizza. Most are terrible. And to find a frozen gluten free pizza is like a finding a diamond. So three weeks aga I was in Windsor (where I grew up and lived until I was 22 and still have family there). Tried Armando’s pizza on Cabana Rd. SOOO excellent. Then I went back and bought 5 frozen pizzas to take on the train back to Hamilton. They fit in two boxes, which I tied together. I asked for one gluten free pizza for my grandson, who must eat gluten free. I have tried all the gluten free pizzas his parents have found and they are dreck. But I took this one to his parents and cooked it following Josh at Armando’s instructions (but 25 degrees lower for fan-running convection oven). They told me they had never cooked a GF frozen pizza before did not know how it would turn out. SOOO excellent, delicious, perfect and just like the non-gluiten free pizza. THAT is worth highlighting. Lots of people make great pizza. NO ONE else makes great gluten free pizza.

Leave a Reply