Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,244 Responses
  1. Jason

    You haven’t had real pizza until you’ve had Lock City Pizza. Lock City is located in Lockport NY & in my opinion is the best pizza!

  2. Matt

    Hey Joe,

    You gotta try Garfalo’s Pizzeria they use cup and char and you won’t be disappointed!

    2500 Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY 14304

  3. Craig Stewart

    Hey Joe,

    If you ever go to the Norfolk County area be sure to check out 2 places. The Barrell Pizza in Simcoe and The Catherwood and the Kiln in Vittoria

  4. Robert

    Hey Joe, if you’re in the Jarvis Ontario Canada area just outside of Hamilton, You should definitely check out Little Johnny’s pizza. I grab a pizza pie from there every week when I drive through with my transport truck. As you could imagine, I eat a lot of pizza because I drive truck a lot and little Johnny’s is one of my favourites in Ontario. I’m sure many people would love to see your review from there. Just a regular cheese and pepperoni pizza.

  5. Eric Tertinek

    Hey Joe

    I know you are running out of spots in Buffalo. As you know I drive all over Buffalo so I dive by lots of pizza places. Here is a list of places you haven’t been to, I have only had one or two of them so these are not my recommendations.

    Tops Friendly Markets – Local grocery chain that serves a cup and char pizza. Known for their breakfast pizza. Most Tops locations sell Battistoni even though they don’t use it on the pizza.

    Marco’s (Near the Peace Bridge) – My buddy Chris loves this place and he is a big time pizza snob, has had the big four in New Haven. He recommends the Fargo, it’s pepperoni & garlic

    Soney Red’s (Lackawanna) – Wood fired pizza oven named Bruno

    PIno’s – Inside O’neils Tavern across the street from the Bills stadium

    Big Tree Inn (by the stadium) This is where the 90’s Bills used to hang out

    Wingnutz (Amherst) Saw a podcast with Eric Wood last week on youtube and he was raving about their pizza. Wings are really good too.

    Forno Napoli (Amherst)

    Hunt Brothers Pizza – Several gas stations have signs saying serving Hunt Brother’s Pizza

    Elm Street Bakery (East Aurora)

    Riverworks (Downtown) – Very cool venue if you’ve never been.

    Balistreri’s Pastries Plus – Known for their tomato pie

  6. Michael

    JOE. YOU HAVE TO TRY THIS PLACE!! It’s called Back Of House pizza. Located at 574 Lancaster St W in Kitchener ON. Their Instagram is backofhousepizza. It’s amazing.

  7. Brandon

    Buffalo pizzeria and deli

    580 Dick Rd Cheektowaga, NY 14225

    I think they have amazing cheese and pepperoni pizza. Pizzeria just stood it out less than a month ago. Pretty pretty good pizza.

  8. One more bestie! This spot does a weekday by the slice deal. Unique pizzas daily. Definitely more NYC than Chicago style. My favorite it the Italian Beef slice, she’s spicy!

    Address: 40 W. 301 IL-64, Wasco, IL 60183

Leave a Reply