Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,244 Responses
  1. Melodie Regester

    If you need a new place to try, my cousins place is in Buffalo !
    Happy eating!! 😊

    Schifano’s Pizzeria

    4923 Genesee St, Cheektowaga, NY 14225

  2. Danny

    Rocco’s pizza and pasta Etobicoke Toronto queensway islington
    The best slice I had in Toronto an I’ve been to a lot of places.
    And If u want a good deep dish u have to try Carson’s in thorld closet Niagara Falls Canadian side

  3. John Hamaty

    Hi Joe, I love your reviews. I’ve lived in Niagara Falls most of my life and I am a true Pizza connoisseur as I can tell you are and I agree with most of your reviews. I think you should check out the Pizza that is at smoke signals in Lewiston, New York. It’s on the reservation. It is an old Niagara Falls recipe that you’ve done a review on before but now that they are doing it, it is actually quite impressive. One of my favorites in Niagara Falls when I order pizza I either order it from La hacienda or Buzzys but now I take a 15 minute ride to go to smoke signals thanks Joe great content Keep up the great reviews

  4. Nick Landers

    Lock City Pizza
    379 Davison Rd
    Lockport, NY 14094

    Stevie V’s Pizzeria
    6318 Robinson Rd
    Lockport, NY 14094

    Frankie’s Pizza & Subs
    1179 Lincoln Ave
    Lockport, NY 14094

    Chop’s Shop
    8405 Rochester Rd
    Gasport, NY 14067

    Ports Pizza & Subs
    8396 State St
    Gasport, NY 14067

    Village Pizzeria
    4 State St
    Middleport, NY 14105

    Avanti Pizza & Wood Fire Kitchen
    500 Main St
    Medina, NY 14103

    Cafora’s Pizza Italian Restaurant
    2885 Main Street
    Newfane, NY 14108

    Wilson’s Pizza Shop
    2730 Main St
    Newfane, NY 14108

  5. Peter J

    Hey Joe,

    If you ever get to Eastern Nova Scotia ya gotta try the pizza from Napoli Pizza in Sydney. That place has been around since the sixties and was and maybe still the best pie in Sydney and also in the college town of Antigonish there is a place called The Wheel. I lived there in the Nineties and they never disapointed.

  6. The pizza at Strikers Lanes in West Seneca, NY is legit. Plenty of charred/cupped pepperoni and delicious melted mozzarella. Bubbly crust that is tender inside and browned with a good chew outside. Their wings are darn good too. Friendly, fast service. Located at 50 Michael Road, West Seneca, NY 14224. ENJOY!

  7. Jim Pollina

    I live in Youngstown N.Y. I grew up in Buffalo so I am use to great pizza. We have nothing out here until 2 months ago. A pizzeria opened on Creek rd called All In Pizza. The owner is friends with the Leonardi family which was the best of the best. It’s like I died and went to pizza heaven.

  8. Joe Volpini

    The Eastern Market 920 Upper Wentworth Hamilton ON. Across from Limeridge Mall. Every Tuesday wood oven pizza. Buy one get one free for $12.99.

  9. Filip Mrsic

    If you’re ever in the port credit area, I would strongly recommend ‘Pizza Nostra’. I have tried them for the very first time and was very amazed how well the pizza was. Dave Portnoy spoke very highly of here and was definitely not wrong. I cannot wait to be back after trying for my first time

Leave a Reply