Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,244 Responses
  1. Paul Leone

    Now that you’re back in WNY, swing by Orchard Park and check out Pappaceno’s or Cappelli’s, both on North Buffalo Street.

  2. Frank Jones

    Give Schifano’s Pizzeria at 4923 Genesee St in Cheektowaga a try… newer business less than a year I believe. Fantastic pizza and great service.

    1. Brandon

      Go to the wildcat in camilus, you won’t be disappointed… Great crunch and great pepperoni, they make sure every pizza is amazing

  3. Billy Duquette jr

    Hey man I live in upstate NY Malone ny 12953 … Punch that in your g.P.Yes.
    There’s at least two or three good pizza joints Where you shouldn’t forget the wings also hahaha . .but “something different ” “Giuseppe’s” and “the pines” are 3 places within 10 min for each other I think you would respect! 🤘 If you show up , let me know what you think man ! Fellow “fat guy ” that LOVES his pizza 🍕!

  4. Being from buffalo I am spoiled by pizza, however I highly want to suggest a place in Fort Erie Ontario called the Sicilian Chef. I had his pizza today and it was fantastic. He makes his own dough and has the pepperoni imported. Also his Sauce is fantastic as well as the cheese of course. The pizza was thick a bit crunchy and I was only able to get through a few pieces considering how substatntial the pie was. Not only was the flavor great his prices are unbeatable. 16$ Canadian for the pie. I took the rest of the pie to my next door neighbors from Calabrese and they loved it.

    Also I have had his spaghetti and my wifes had the lasagna both hearty tastey and very cost effective. I also purcahsed his sauce for meatloaf and it was pheonomenal. The owner is extreemly friendly, greets guests in his place. This is a treat that Fort Erie, ON got.

  5. Tim Durfy

    You should try LOCK CITY PIZZA a Lockport”s Legendary Pizza Joint on Davison rd ,the recipe goes back into the 50″s from PONTILLOS of Batavia , and same recipe at CAFORAS Pizza and Spaghetti rt 78 Newfane .not gonna have cup n char tho

  6. Russell

    you need to come back to Lockport you missed a whole bunch of pizzerias there Stevie V’s lockCity Pizza Frankie’s Pizza The village eatery and probably even more

  7. Ryan Simpson

    Hello Joe! Love your videos! Been watching Dave for years now and it is a refreshing to have someone new in the game, especially for the WNY area. There is a relatively new place on Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls NY called Garfalo’s. We have not had their Gold Medal Pizza yet, but have had their Artisan and it was delicious. Keep up the great work man! Go Bills!

  8. Ry Nasty

    Go to Tony’s Pizza in Akron, NY. Tony’s has been around since the 1950’s. One of the owners named TJ is straight out of 1980’s movie. Usually has some chest hair coming out of his shirt and he’s the ultimate pizza pie maker.

    1. Papa’s Pizza in the previous Koz Pizza location in Sunset Plaza on Camp Rd. In Hamburg, NY is one of the best Pizzas I have ever eaten. We’ll worth the trip.

  9. Shawn

    Dawn K makes the best pizza in Cheektowaga, NY in my opinion! She has the spicy Philly Cheesesteak to the 3 meat 3 cheese pizza.

Leave a Reply