Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,244 Responses
  1. Jack Steven Harmatys

    Try BUZZYS pizza in Niagara Falls it is the best pizza I have ever had I live in Maine now and have not had it in years I know you will love it!

  2. Dawn

    You’ve gotta give Maria’s in Angola on Erie Road a try! Unlike others, the pizza has some weight to it. Not skimpy with the toppings. I just ordered a large, 1/2 pepperoni, the other half with sweet peppers and onions. Must have weighed 5lbs easy. It’s saucy, cheesy, and loaded with toppings. Great crust too! I was full after 1 slice!! Give it a try!! Id attach a pic of if I could, lol

  3. Dustin

    Here are a few standout Pizza spots that I highly recommend in Rochester, NY. They will make your trip out here worth it.

    These are not in any particular order…

    Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage
    1157 Culver Rd,
    Rochester, NY 14609

    https://peelsonwheelspizza.com/

    https://www.facebook.com/peelsonwheelspizza?mibextid=ZbWKwL

    Dough Boyz
    Rochester, NY

    https://www.doughboyzroc.com/

    https://www.facebook.com/doughboyzroc?mibextid=ZbWKwL

    Pizza Wizard
    760 S Clinton Ave,
    Rochester, NY 14620

    https://www.pizzawizard.pizza/

    https://www.facebook.com/pizzawizardroc?mibextid=ZbWKwL

  4. H.D. Burley

    Try out Leaning Tower on Main Street in Dansville, NY! Long-time pizza establishment that is under new ownership. While you’re in town, check out the few others too on Main Street.

  5. Jacob Luick

    If you’re still in Lockport, try and go about 5-10 East to Gasport at Chop’s Shop. Have loved their pizza for forever. High suggest getting the sweet sauce!

  6. George

    Santora’s on main east Port Colborne da bomb feta like your mamas p.s. seen you rocking those kicks yesterday that artist gave you nice

  7. Sonny Red’s Lackawanna NY. Just got ranked buffalos top wings as well. 5 min from South Buffalo. Excellent wood fired pizza, my favorite!

  8. Shane Gross

    If you are in Lockport you have to try Pizza Oven. Super sweet sauce (the reason Lockport like sweet sauce) but you will want to drink it!

  9. Hey there! I’m not certain if you’ve ever been to the Grain House in Barker (just north of Lockport), but I recommend you try their pizza! They have both traditional and sweet sauce to choose from and choice of traditional or cup and char pepperoni. I personally prefer cup and char with bacon and sweet sauce. Try it out and would love your thoughts on it!
    And this Saturday just happens to be the Corn Festival; stop down for pizza, beer, and some fantastic fireworks!

  10. Stephen Smelski

    Batavia is close by, pizza151, ficerellas, batavias original, romans (wood fired), main st pizza, Jerry arenas

  11. Nick Benton

    If you make your way down the thruway, definitely check out some Rochester spots. Pontillo’s is a local chain that rarely misses, Good Guys is great, Guida’s is great (but their regular pie is too thiccc for me, get the thin crust). Giuseppe’s is excellent. My favorite is Pizza Stop though. Most places have cup and curl pepp, but you may have to ask for it. Any questions, let me know. Keep up the great work!

  12. If you are still in Lockport NY. Please try Lake Effect Ice cream 79 Canal st Lockport NY. They have a review worthy ice cream called Red Hot. It is infused with Franks Red Hot sauce. I know it’s not pizza , but it’s summer time , and this is a wild flavor

  13. Mike Johnson

    Not sure if you have been there yet but Papas Pizza in West Seneca is definitely one of the best I’ve ever had. I’m a pizza fanatic and wouldn’t waste your time with a Mediocre recommendation

Leave a Reply