Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,246 Responses
  1. John

    Come down to Lewiston, NY — tons of spots all within a few blocks of eachother on or around Center St.!

    A few I would highly recommend:

    -Vincenzo’s (742 Center St.)
    -Favorite’s Pizza (781 Cayuga St.)
    -Casa Antica (490 Center St) open dinner time .. great Italian food and fantastic pizza that you can takeout
    -Gallo Coal Fire Kitchen (402 Center Street)
    -Hustlers Tavern (800 Center Street) — brand new just opened

    In Youngstown (5 min further away)
    -Main Street Pizzeria (311 Main St.) one of my personal favorites
    -Grandma D’s Pizza (3909 Creek Rd)

  2. Nichole

    You should give Good Guy’s in North Tonawanda a try!

    “You won’t get a heartier, thicker, heavier, cheesier, greasier, saucier square of pizza than here up in North Tonawanda.” – Sources from good guys website

  3. John

    If you’re still in the NF, NY area, Lewiston is just down the road. We have tons of local pizza spots but my favorite is Vincenzo’s (address below). I’d recommend the square tray. Subs and wings are killer too.

    Vincenzo’s Pizza House

    742 Center Street
    Lewiston, NY – US

  4. Patrick Brierley

    Forno napoli, jays Artisan pizza, Bocce Club, Picassos, francos, la nova, mister pizza, gino and joes, mustachios, raymondos, bob and johns

  5. Chris

    Please do Goodfellas in down town Niagara Falls, New York. The best in the city also they don’t use cheap school pizza pepperoni like Buzzys and Broadway Pizza. It’s real pepperoni.

  6. Dean

    You should come to Dundas just on the edge of Hamilton and review the shops there. Beyond the chains there are some sweet pizza’s to be had.

    1. Jay

      Here’s some of the best pizza joints in London Ontario (in no particular order):

      Zen’Za
      Through Thick & Thin
      Pizza Projekt
      Formaggio’s Pie Shack
      Richmoor’s Pizzeria
      Byron Pizza
      Sultan Pizza
      Soprano’s Pizza
      Rico’s Pizzeria
      Muldoon’s Pizza
      Lord Gainsborough’s

      I hope you can make it over here and try these spots out! Thanks!

    2. André Margaça

      If you’re ever in Staten Island, NY go to Joe & Pats Pizzeria, 1754 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY

      Also try Nonna’s Pizza,
      27 Brower Ct, Staten Island, NY

    3. Doug Castile

      Next time your in the falls on the us side, try joeys pizza on Buffalo avenue in lasalle and ventrys on Niagara falls Blvd. both have great pizza and cup n char.

    1. Joe, you and I spoke about this place through messenger. It’s a CLASSIC and a must. It is said that this pizzeria is the 2nd oldest continuously running pizzeria in the United States. I highly suggest getting a Sausage, Pepper, and Onion Pizza here. Also be sure to ask where you can get the best Chicken Riggues and Utica Greens while you’re in town. Those are 2 Utica delicacies that the majority of people who try them live the rest of their lives chasing those flavors.
      O’Scugnizzo Pizzeria Utica, NY
      (315) 732-6149 https://www.google.com/search?client=ms-android-verizon&sxsrf=AJOqlzXb3hdu-oWrywrybQfzZ1nc7pws1A:1677669575801&q=O'Scugnizzo+Pizzeria&ludocid=12035684156613154049&gsas=1&client=ms-android-verizon&ibp=gwp;0,7&lsig=AB86z5WBgpfePvGCPqitNC0vqOHr&kgs=97902a9e0dca301b&shndl=-1&shem=lssle&source=sh/x/kp/local/2

      https://www.facebook.com/UticaPizza

      Uticapizza.com

  7. Mike Fiutko

    Hey Joe, You have to try LaHacienda in Niagara Falls, NY … New York style thin crust… They are open at 4pm everyday but Tuesday Their on Pine Ave and Hyde Park Blvd… phone number is 716 285 2536… others on my list would be Sammy’s….Mr Ventry’s … Joey’s pizzeria.. please do yourself a favor and go to LaHacienda

    1. Allan Heinrich

      Sammy’s used to be good in the 80’s, but when I recently gave them a retry I was very disappointed. The Lahacienda still rocks after all these years and considering a new owner rather recently. Mr. Ventry’s on pierce Avenue in the hood has the shi`tiest most flavorless pizza I’ve ever had in my 63 years on this earth. It’s now bucks pizza and you would think the dumb ass would have made it his own and not kept it the same junk that Mr. Ventry’s was putting out. Joey’s on Buffalo Avenue rocks as it has for the 30 plus years I’ve been enjoying their products. But an absolute must try is The Little Bakery just down from Joey’s at the corner of Buffalo Avenue and River road in the reddish colored building. The pizza rocks, and the just started selling wings, mozzarella sticks, fish fries besides their signature Trusello’s original recipe Italian bread and old fashioned pizza. You’ll love this place and particularly the owners and the staff, they are always helping the people in the community including our BELOVED first responders.

  8. AJ Speier

    While in Buffalo, you should check out JJ’s Casa Di Pizza, Franco’s (5 locations), Santora’s Pizza Pub & Grill (3 locations) & Picasso’s (4 locations)

Leave a Reply