Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,242 Responses
  1. Randy Soby

    Raymondo’s Pizza in Cheektowaga NY. One of the best doughs I’ve had in Buffalo. Quality ingredients. A little crunch in every bite. Give it a whirl. Thicker and you don’t have to fork and knife it. Nice Buffalo style pie.

  2. Joe Volpini

    Cowabunga 2 30 Vine St. off James St. Hamilton ON. The Eastern Market 920 Upper Wentworth Hamilton ON. Across from Limeridge Mall. 2 for 1 for 12.99 wood oven. Checker’s Pizza six-sixty-five Plains Rd. E. Burlington ON. Super Torino’s Pizza 521 Hwy 8 Stoney Creek ON.

  3. Joe Volpini

    Cowabunga 2 30 Vine St. Off James St. Hamilton ON. The Eastern Market 920 Upper Wentworth across from Limeridge Mall. Every Tuesday for $12.99 wood oven. Checker’s Pizza 665 Plains Rd E. Burlington ON. Super Torino’s 521 Hwy 8 Stoney Creek ON.

  4. Heart of Sicily
    N. George St EXT’D
    York,Pa(Emigsville)

    Love sausage/pepperoni pie, but Joe,know it’s not close to home, but I get slices from here regularly, JUST PLAIN, REALLy darn good, tastes just like the name of establishment says, The Heart of Sicily! Also, Squires in Dundalk,MD, Pizza John’s in Essex,MD, Pizza el Bacio in York,PA for your pepperoni. Just my purveyance of my travels. No Artisan, so whole basil, straight up pizza. Love your gig, keep up the good work! Ya ever make it down to Philly/central Penna region, hit me up, we’ll hit em. My next trip north, I’ll look ya up.

  5. Jon

    Mcneely, by far the best place is John & Mary’s on Millersport ave in Getzville. It’s the only John & Mary’s location whose pizza is far superior than the other locations. TRUST ME!!!!!

    1. Joe Volpini

      Cowabunga 2 30 Vine St. Off James St. Hamilton ON. The Eastern Market Upper Wentworth across from Limeridge Mall 2 for 1 for $12.99. Wood oven. Checker’s Pizza 665 Plains Rd E Burlington ON. Super Torino’s 521 Hwy 8 Stoney Creek ON.

  6. Joe Volpini

    Cowabunga 2 30 Vine St Hamilton ON off James St. The Eastern Market 920 Upper Wentworth across from Limeridge Mall Hamilton ON. Checker’s Pizza 665 Plains Rd E. Burlington ON. Super Torino’s 521 Hwy 8 Stoney Creek ON.

  7. David Goodman

    Naked City Pizza – 3345 Delaware Ave, Kenmore NY 14217

    Buffalo Pizza Bistro – 388 Porter Ave, Buffalo NY 14201

    The New Imperial Pizza on Main St -1661 Main St Buffalo NY 14209

    1. Jake G

      Giovanni snack bar and heartbreaker’s are the best pizza in Ottawa.

      Giovannis specifically is an old school, mom and pop Italian joint. Best in ottawa

  8. Geresi’s Pizza in Sarnia, Ontario, Canada. – That’s all that needs to be said.

    My favorite is double pep and Xtra cheese. Oh man oh man. Home run pizza!

    I know what kind of pizza you like and I’m pretty sure you will love this!

  9. Bakes

    Fire up a hockey rink canteen pizza contest. I recommend the canteen at Strathcona Paper Center in Napanee. Their fries have been voted best in area and they recently started pumping out high end pies too. Definitely recommend.

  10. Joe Volpini

    Cowabunga 2 30 Vine St. Off James St. The Eastern Market 920 Upper Wentworth. Across from Limeridge Mall 2 for 1 12.99. Checker’s Pizza 665 Plains Rd E. Burlington ON. Super Torino’s Pizza. 521 Hwy 8 Stoney Creek ON.

  11. Mike Grisanti

    Joe,
    Campi’s Pizza in Dunkirk, NY definitely has the thickness pizza you’ll ever eat. They have a unique braided crust. Not sure if they actually have a pizza shop, but they are a big vendor at the Buffalo Italian Festival every year. Give them a call and make the trip if they’re open. You can only eat one slice.

Leave a Reply