Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,242 Responses
  1. John campbell

    Joe, Try Pie O Mine 3229 Southwestern Blvd Orchard Park, Ny Brick oven pizza. Super good especially the next day in a Air Fryer.

  2. Joe Volpini

    Cowabunga 2 30 Vine St. off James St. Hamilton ON. The Eastern Market 920 Upper Wentworth Hamilton ON. Across directly from Limeridge Mall. 2 for 1 every Tuesday wood oven pizza. Super Torino’s Hwy 8 Stoney Creek ON. Checker’s Pizza six-sixty-five Plains Rd. E. Burlington ON.

  3. Carlos Tejada

    Alright Joey –

    Next time you’re in the Buffalo area you need to try:

    * Maria’s in Angola (9120 Erie Road)
    * Great Lakes Pizza Company in West Seneca (444 Indian Church Road)
    * Plaza Pizza in Tonawanda (260 Main Street)

    Looking forward to your review and enjoy the Za…….

  4. Joe Volpini

    Cowabunga 2 30 Vine St. Off James St. The Eastern Market 920 Upper Wentworth across from Limeridge Mall Every Tuesday 2 for 1 wood oven pizza. For $12.99. Checker’s Pizza 665 Plains Rd. E. Burlington ON. Super Torino’s Hwy 8 Stoney Creek ON.

    1. George Opera

      Lock City in Lockport would probably be right up you alley. Delicious,consistent pizza made by people who care. I’d be shocked if it scored below 9

    1. Mike C

      Mr. Pizza on Elmwood and Bird in Buffalo NY. It will give that pizza you had at Mattinas a run for its money.
      Been asking for this one a few times! Mr. pizza! On Elmwood!

  5. Derek Tymorek

    Joe,
    You need to try Naked City Pizza on Delaware in Kenmore down the street from Jay’s Artisan Pizza.
    Half sheet of cheese and pepperone’s on Tuesday is a steal at $15 and it is amazing.

    Thanks for the reviews, they are awesome!!!

  6. Shari Cardinale

    Delta sonic has a wood fired pizza. Locations on niagara falls blvd. At maple rd. In amherst or transit rd. in williamsville. Wouldn’t think a gas station/car wash would be good but delicious!!

Leave a Reply