Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
5,245 Responses
  1. Brian Legault

    Come back to Peterborough and Pizza Shack is an absolute must. And don’t forget to stop by the Pizza Pizza on George Street (My store)

  2. Marc

    Hey Joe, if youre ever in Mississauga, two of the best pizza places are JP Pizzeria (5850 Churchill Meadows Blvd) and Marconi Pizza (3635 Cawthra Road). Almost sure you will rate these as 9 plus

  3. Cavan

    Joe, I highly recommend Power Pizza on Ottawa st in Hamilton. Great pizza. Ask for the New Yorker. (Cheese and cup n char) Just beautiful pizza. Right up there with Cowanunga.

    1. Crystal

      Stromboli’s pizza in brantford with the brick oven sauce or Maria’s pizza orginal also in brantford and both small owned businesses.

      1. Michael Barbadoro

        Joe, you gotta try Valentinos! There’s 2 locations zone in Hamilton (Westdale) one one on Stoney Creek mountain. My goto pizza!

  4. Herb

    Try Chicago Style on Hamilton east mountain on Upper Sherman and Brucesdale.Been around a long time quality ingredients and great taste. A little pricey but satisfying.

  5. Tom Nazzaro

    If you ever are in Jamestown, NY go to Lena’s pizza. Also the go to in Jamestown is Johnny’s Lunch. They are famous for their hot dogs and burgers. Order the sauce though

  6. Eilea Given

    I can’t believe you haven’t tried Dominic’s stone fired pizza in Fonthill! Hopefully they’ll make your next rankings!

    1. Stopped in at Maurizio’s Pizzeria in Parry Sound today and wow wow wow. Got a Romanian Pepperoni Woodfried Pizza and it was amazing. Smokey, thin crust pizza with an amazing sauce. Definitely will be back and worth the drive.

  7. PizzaManStan

    Go to Flora Pizzeria! Why? Because. Is it goodest? Yes! Roman style pizza, cup and char (although you may need some extra spice because you like it spicy). It’s a head scratcher as the first bite is good, but then as you keep eating it you’ll wonder how many pizzas can you say you’ve had that are better than this? It’s top tier.

  8. Give Gather Café a try. We’d love for you to visit our cafe to try our wood fired pizza.
    We currently run the oven Thursday to Saturday from 4 to 7pm.
    We are located in Alton (Caledon) Ontario.
    Cheers

  9. Gregb

    Favorites Pizza and Wings in Lewiston, NY. Best pizza I’ve ever had!

    If you have 10-15 people working behind the counter is a pizza shop you know it’s good.

    Its only 7 minutes across the border from the Queenston/Lewiston Bridge. Worth the trip!

    1. David Ryley

      2nd Request

      Elevator Bistro in Burlington on Pearle St (around the corner from Son of a peach in Burlington)

      Neapolitan style Pizza
      Insta: @elevatorbistro

Leave a Reply