Great spot
Craig Street Pizza- Parksville Vancouver Island
Hey Joe, finally scrolled down enough to post a recommendation. Bella Pizza, Lackawanna Location. 3330 South Park Ave. Lackawanna, NY 14218. Most consistent pizza I have had. Seems to never change over the 40 years I have tried it. They have other locations also but Lackawanna is the original and the best.
In Vancouver BC a few nice spots for Pie!
Pepino’s
The Firewood Café
Zaccary’s Pizza
Johnny’s on Oak
Joe!!!! Try Garfalo's Pizza 2500 Niagara Falls Blvd in Niagara Falls, NY but technically it's in Wheatfield, NY. Just opened and it has immediately made it to my Top 6. Fresh crispy dough, good sauce and the ole cup-and-char. I compared it Sammy's which is my go-to every Friday.
Carbone’s Pizza , Alden Ny
Cup char is excellent along with the mild sauce. Crust is nicely cooked and has good cheese. A bit thick for NY style but worth a stop!
Check out Rozs pizza in South Cheektowaga Ny. Family owned and operated for 46 years. Awesome pizza wings and subs give it a try.
Check out Rozs pi,zza. Family owned and operated for 46 Years. In South Cheektowaga. Great pizza subs and wings
Ferro's Pizza
3521 Seneca street
West Seneca, NY
It's the closest thing to NYC pizza you'll get in Western New York. And I saw how much you loved the pizza on Bleecker street in NYC. It's a perfect thin crust and cheese to sauce ratio. And it does that thing where the oil meets the sauce and it creates a blush colored sauce. Trust me.
Try Maria's Pizza in Brantford Ontario...they have been around since 1969 and it is very old school Italian. Locals love it.
.
Try both locations while you are there.
Try this. My fave pizza so far! Pappa's Pizza Oven. This place rocks. Borderlines Imperial and Bocce pizza but better then both. They offer two sauce's, regular and sweet so go with the regular. 12 piece cut is all over the place in size slices but we like it because if you just want that little more put not a whole slice you can grab a smaller slice. YUMMY!
You should review Now Pizzaria in Hamburg. I live in Hamburg-the ONLY place I will get a pizza from!