Want Joe to visit a pizzeria?

Previous recommendations

La Pizza Club, 1511 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216

Have you considered doing any NY style pizza reviews

Or a Buffalo style thick crust VS NY style thin crust reviews

Have you considered coming to the Syracuse NY area for reviews

I'm curious to see what your take would be on NY style

Scott Farcus

I second the recommendation of Good Guys in North Tonawanda. Or even Fat Man’s pizza in Tonawanda on Niagara Falls above. Both are the best in the area!

Try Muscarellas pizza in Lancaster, NY

Muscarellas pizza
470 Aurora street
Lancaster, NY 14086
(716) 683-1000

4.8 stars out of 5 !!!

Zack dudziak

Hey Joe Zack Dudziak again. I live in a small town with 2 pizzerias. Both very good. Eatsa pizza eden ny 14057 and eden pizza and seafood eden ny 14057. Would love if you'd make the trek out here to try them and I'd love to join you on the reviews!

Jessica Wagner

Go to good guys pizza place in north Tonawanad and try their pizza on Ruie and Nash road in north Tonawanad

Julia Rohrback

I'm from buffalo but my recent favorite is from Mikeys late night slice
457 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215

Please do Lock city Pizza on Davison Rd while in Lockport

Joe, did you try Lock City Pizza while you were in Lockport? It's been awhile since I had their pizza but I remember it being pretty good.

Kevin Karas

Check out Ferros Famous in West Seneca. NYC style pizza. Excellent!!!!!

Ray Outwater

Can you try Taste of Italy in Latham NY? Their pizza is supposed to be the best in the 518 area code.

Please score Pizza Oven in Lockport NY. You have to order it well done though

Vickie Ramsey

Chop shop in Gasport, New York. I enjoy the large with pepperoni, sweet sauce and garlic crust. I think you would enjoy it I haven’t seen it on your site yet. Please give it a try.

Brian Koch

Papas pizza oven lancaster ny. Surprised you haven't heard the reviews- gonna be a high score

Hoagie Hounds in Tonawanda NY 14223! New place - Great pizza & huge Hoagies!

Medwin Ackerley

Demarco's Pizza, Scotia , New York. 12302. The best pizza in this area for sure. I love the pepperoni pizza. We are a suburb of Schenectady, New York. Ten miles from the Capitol of New York, Albany. Sorry I'm computer challenged so I don't know how to send you the website but if you go online I'm sure you can easily find it

David Dunnett

Pizza Monster, Montreal Rd, Kingston ON.