Want Joe to visit a pizzeria?

Previous recommendations

Nick J Manzare

Brickoven on Grand Island will be worth the trip!
Recommend the Sicilian if you can handle the heat .

Try Frankie's Donuts on Portage in NF and Good Guys in North Tonawanda!

Hey Joe try the new York round pepperoni at castelli mercato in ancaster ontario. The pizza gets cooked to a nice char and they are not shy on the cup n char.
They also have Roman style pepperoni that looks good.

Marco Soffritti

CASANOVA RISTORANTE
3041 military rd
Niagara Falls NY 14303

Consistent, Quality, and Friendly service....Many of the kitchens vegetables are sourced from their garden directly behind restaurant. Great family owned restaurant with excellent pizza 🍕

The Village Eatery in Lockport NY on Davison Road please.

Matt Zeigler

LaNova's Pizzeria - 371 West Ferry Street Buffalo, NY 14213, come on down Joe and I'll share a pie or two with you

Come down to Lewiston, NY — tons of spots all within a few blocks of eachother on or around Center St.!

A few I would highly recommend:

-Vincenzo’s (742 Center St.)
-Favorite’s Pizza (781 Cayuga St.)
-Casa Antica (490 Center St) open dinner time .. great Italian food and fantastic pizza that you can takeout
-Gallo Coal Fire Kitchen (402 Center Street)
-Hustlers Tavern (800 Center Street) — brand new just opened

In Youngstown (5 min further away)
-Main Street Pizzeria (311 Main St.) one of my personal favorites
-Grandma D’s Pizza (3909 Creek Rd)

You should give Good Guy's in North Tonawanda a try!

“You won't get a heartier, thicker, heavier, cheesier, greasier, saucier square of pizza than here up in North Tonawanda.” - Sources from good guys website

If you’re still in the NF, NY area, Lewiston is just down the road. We have tons of local pizza spots but my favorite is Vincenzo’s (address below). I’d recommend the square tray. Subs and wings are killer too.

Vincenzo’s Pizza House

742 Center Street
Lewiston, NY - US

Patrick Brierley

Forno napoli, jays Artisan pizza, Bocce Club, Picassos, francos, la nova, mister pizza, gino and joes, mustachios, raymondos, bob and johns

Try good guys pizza in north Tonawanda..Brando's pizza in north Tonawanda...Mayers pizza in north Tonawanda...

You need to try “Junction Style” pizza from “the grill on Erie” in North Tonawanda… legit the best pizza in WNY…

Please do Goodfellas in down town Niagara Falls, New York. The best in the city also they don’t use cheap school pizza pepperoni like Buzzys and Broadway Pizza. It’s real pepperoni.

Vinni Mancino

Gino's Pizza Place- 351 Fries Road Tonawanda NY 14150

You should come to Dundas just on the edge of Hamilton and review the shops there. Beyond the chains there are some sweet pizza's to be had.

Picassos Pizza, Francos Pizza and Lovejoy Pizza in Buffalo!!

Trattoria in Kirkland and Cugini's in Beaconsfield. Both in the West Island of Montreal. Check it out !