Want Joe to visit a pizzeria?

Previous recommendations

Tim Glaz

Wise Guys pizza I think is the best in Buffalo. Seneca St. South Buffalo. Excellent ! I've had alot of pizza from plenty of places but this place stands out big time ! Let's see if you agree. I think you will

Jeff Haas

Fatmans, imperial, good guys, wurlitzer. You could do all but imperial in one day because of the closeness of them.

Margo Smith

Hello!!

You MUST try Lock City Pizza!! They're located at 379 Davison Rd, Lockport, NY 14094.

Family owned for 50+ years. I honestly don't know exactly, but I definitely ate their pizza as a small child, lol.

I've never had a pizza like it. Very unique flavors and crust is super crispy and yet, chewy. Not thick and yet not thin. There's just a handful of tables to dine in, so they do mostly takeout. They have plexiglass around where they prep, so you can even watch them making the pizza. I remember as a kid and my children experienced the occasional "oops" of ingredients being tossed at us while watching. I remember my kids look the first time, thinking they'd be covered in toppings or dough tossed at the glass, lol. They don't have a website (they don't need it, lol) and their Facebook page is rarely used. They DO, however have 4.3⭐️ on Facebook and Google!

When you come to Lockport, you can also try another pretty unique pizza at Pizza Oven. They're located close to Lock City at 54 Vine St. https://www.lockportpizzaoven.com/

This pizza is unique with its super thin crust and pretty sweet sauce with cup and char pepperoni.

Both places also cut their pies into squares/rectangles and don't open until 4pm. To me that kinda says a lot as they're both always busy and we usually have to wait an hour for either.

Hope you're ready to try some pretty unique and delicious pies in Lockport, NY!!

Catherine chaisson

I moved here in 2019 from Albany NY (which also has amazing pizza spots!), but so far, Jaco’s on Buffalo Avenue Niagara Falls, NY, Ventries (downtown & Niagara Falls Blvd location) have amazing pizza as well.

Vicki Glynn

Forno Napoli in Amherst (Wood Fired pizza)
Mattina’s in Kenmore
Pizza Amore North Tonawanda

John and Sue

My son and I were watching your videos and we highly recommend you try Sughetto's La Pizza Shoppe in Kleinburg. My 7 Year old son is a pizza connesieur and he says its the best he's had yet. The shoppe owner is a true artisan pizzaiolo. His prices are not on the cheaper side, but he uses fresh, quality ingredients and we truly believe its an experience worth making the drive for.

They are located in the town of Kleinburg (York Region) at
10462 Islington Avenue,
Kleinburg, Ontario
L0J 1C0

Would love to see you review them.

You should try the Wurlitzer Pizza co on Nash Rd in North Tonawanda. Make sure to also try there Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza. Great stuff

Brother Neil

Hey Joe, if you want to try the secret menu item at Pizzaiolo let me know! It's a KD (kraft dinner) pizza. Not your usually fare buy it looks interesting. Check them out on IG.

If you're cruising around Western New York, check out Favorites in Lewiston

Good Guy's Pizza, corner of Nash Road and Ruie Road in North Tonawanda, NY. The best Pizza in the world (in my opinion). I live in Nashville, TN but what I wouldn't give for a slice of that goodness!

Please review NINO'S & PASQUALES in West Seneca, NY

Andrew Palmer

METRO PIZZA on Clinton Street buffalo NY. AMAZING PIZZA ITS A HIDDEN GEM

Papa's Pizzaland (The sauce is a bit different between locations)

Address: 113 Peter St, Port Hope, ON L1A 1C5, Canada
Address: 541 William St, Cobourg, ON K9A 3A4, Canada

Georgies pizza akron ny! All home made sauce for pizza and wings, get the thin crust , he offers both thick and thin.

La Nova pizza in Buffalo

George’s pizza Niagara Falls

DAN PARKER

One pie pizza 2185 Clinton st Buffalo

Jeremy davidson

Mattinas pizzeria on Delaware Ave Tonawanda ny and good guys pizza in north Tonawanda are the 2 best ones left in the area that you haven't reviewed