Discover the BEST Pizza in Your City!

Know a Pizza Joint Joe Has to Try?

Leave a comment below, try and provide as much information as possible, link to their website or Facebook/social page is a great start!
4,717 Responses
  1. Chris

    Slowhand Sourdough Detroit Style Pizza

    99 Pape Ave, Toronto, ON M4M 2V7

    Pineapple Express…If you like the crunch, just do it!

  2. Hello Joe,

    Great job, love watching your pizza reviews!

    I am recommending Sorrentino’s Spaghetti House on Main Street in Williamsville. You will love the cup and char!

  3. Wayne Bleich

    Brick Oven Pizza
    2457 Grand Island Blvd
    Grand Island ,NY

    Say Cheese
    1771 Love Rd
    Grand Island ,NY

    Mallwitz’s Island Lanes
    1887 Whitehaven Rd
    Grand Island ,NY

    All three of these have very good pizza.

  4. J.T.

    Sorrentinos, main st williamsville

    Johnny’s union rd cheektowaga

    Molinaros at niagara county produce market transit rd lockport

  5. Neil Fabricated

    How about wood fire pepperoni and jalapeño pizza at Wookcock Brewery in Wilson N. Y It was the best I’ve ever had.

  6. Bella Pizza
    3330​ South Park Avenue
    Lackawanna, NY 14218
    Tel: 716.822.6242
    HOURS
    Every Day
    11am-10pm

    Great pizza, tons of cheese, right amount of sauce, little greasy from the cup & char, but one of the best pizzas in the Southtowns.

    1. Drew

      Batavias best pizza….route 5 in Batavia, not only do they have the biggest slices available for lunch at a reasonable price, but they have by far the best pizza I. The western NY area….the right amount of cheese, the right amount sauce (and it is the best sauce!!) cup and char pepp, perfectly foldable, perfect crust, and the right amount of grease….believe me u won’t be disappointed!! Also please try there pizza calzones! The staff is incredibly friendly and super hardworking!!

  7. Steve

    Garfalo’s on Niagara Falls Boulevard. They’re new, I live in the neighborhood and it’s so good and I want it to stay in business because we’ve been through so many bad pizza shops we finally got a good one.

Leave a Reply